Who's Online
1 registered (Lagerpmp), 0 Guests and 7 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Brewer Of The Month
CURRENT BOTM
MAY 2012
natural320
Top Posters
Jon_TWR 12000
mamiata1 11688
D Rock 11131
Dr. Dink 9047
BigNastyBrew 8679
Site links
Mr Beer FAQ Mr. Beer Fans Map
Today's Birthdays
Frosty
Newest Members
fdsafaf, Cptmoney, iamtek7, belgio9, Michael Otero
3868 Registered Users
Forum Stats
3868 Members
35 Forums
19421 Topics
270696 Posts

Max Online: 196 @ 06/11/11 07:04 PM
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#251494 - 01/08/12 08:41 PM tiny stout yeast trial
gobucks747 Offline
“Good people drink good beer.” HST
Jr. Mr Beer Fan
*

Registered: 10/14/11
Posts: 113
Loc: Haverhill, MA
So, I mixed up 5ish gal batch of stout and separated into two mr beers. All extract... Muntons HME, Briess UME.

One batch I am using a safale us-05, the other a safale s-04

I need to see for myself the difference between an english ale yeast and american ale yeast. Both are pushing 1.060 initial gravity.
_________________________
Fermenting: empty
Fermenting: empty
Fermenting: empty
Conditioning: motts hard cider
Conditioning: Double Wheres the honey stout
Conditioning: Yeast trial stouts
drinking: Muntons Mexican
drinking: Oatmeal red v2.0



Drinking: Double Straw(cherry) ale

“Good people drink good beer.”
― Hunter S. Thompson

Top
#251496 - 01/08/12 08:53 PM Re: tiny stout yeast trial [Re: gobucks747]
Bitter_Bob Offline
Ultimate Mr. Beer Fan
****

Registered: 10/28/08
Posts: 2802
Loc: Columbus, GA
Sounds good.

I personally like S05. Like my stouts dry and with LOTS of roasted barley. I have used both before in a stout, but not in a split batch scenario.

Keep us posted.
_________________________
Brewing Since: 10/12/08

Fermenting: Wheat IPA
Carbing: Ordinary Bitter
Conditioning: Standard Lager, Vienna, MaiBock
Drinking: Best Bitter, 1885 Scottish IP, Dry Stout, 80/-, Harp clone, Braggot
On Deck: Scottish 60/-

Top
#251503 - 01/08/12 09:10 PM Re: tiny stout yeast trial [Re: Bitter_Bob]
Jon_TWR Global Moderator Online   happy
I'm the white rabbit.
Brewmeister Dubbel
****

Registered: 12/17/09
Posts: 12000
Loc: Brooklyn, NY
This is a great experiment. Definitely keep us posted!
_________________________
CCBBA Yeast Trials

Favorite recipes:
Drunken Druid (Mr. Beer),JPA (All Grain)...there are more that go here, I will add them later.

Wines and Ciders:
House Red
Apfelwein

Top
#251911 - 01/11/12 03:26 PM Re: tiny stout yeast trial [Re: Jon_TWR]
gobucks747 Offline
“Good people drink good beer.” HST
Jr. Mr Beer Fan
*

Registered: 10/14/11
Posts: 113
Loc: Haverhill, MA
update
Day 9 readings
safale 04 English is 1.019 and looks darker and had zero carbonation when it was going into the hydrometer. Flat as a pancake and the reading took two seconds.

safale 05 American is also 1.019 but was very carbonated in the hydro and took quite a while before I could even take a clear reading. A little lighter
_________________________
Fermenting: empty
Fermenting: empty
Fermenting: empty
Conditioning: motts hard cider
Conditioning: Double Wheres the honey stout
Conditioning: Yeast trial stouts
drinking: Muntons Mexican
drinking: Oatmeal red v2.0



Drinking: Double Straw(cherry) ale

“Good people drink good beer.”
― Hunter S. Thompson

Top
#252541 - 01/16/12 10:06 AM Re: tiny stout yeast trial [Re: gobucks747]
gobucks747 Offline
“Good people drink good beer.” HST
Jr. Mr Beer Fan
*

Registered: 10/14/11
Posts: 113
Loc: Haverhill, MA
bottled it on 1/15. Looked about the same and stayed at 1.019 The English one is looking very tasty.
_________________________
Fermenting: empty
Fermenting: empty
Fermenting: empty
Conditioning: motts hard cider
Conditioning: Double Wheres the honey stout
Conditioning: Yeast trial stouts
drinking: Muntons Mexican
drinking: Oatmeal red v2.0



Drinking: Double Straw(cherry) ale

“Good people drink good beer.”
― Hunter S. Thompson

Top
#254928 - 01/31/12 08:43 PM Re: tiny stout yeast trial [Re: gobucks747]
gobucks747 Offline
“Good people drink good beer.” HST
Jr. Mr Beer Fan
*

Registered: 10/14/11
Posts: 113
Loc: Haverhill, MA
After two weeks priming, and a couple days in the fridge, initial results.
The american is very green. Holds great sustained head. It will be a nice bitter stout when done.
The English was barely carbonated, didn't prime.

The english are going to warm storage of 70-72 for two weeks to hopefully get carbonated.

Both were stored in 58-62 degree storage for two weeks to bottle prime.

Will be back in a few more weeks smile




Edited by gobucks747 (01/31/12 08:45 PM)
_________________________
Fermenting: empty
Fermenting: empty
Fermenting: empty
Conditioning: motts hard cider
Conditioning: Double Wheres the honey stout
Conditioning: Yeast trial stouts
drinking: Muntons Mexican
drinking: Oatmeal red v2.0



Drinking: Double Straw(cherry) ale

“Good people drink good beer.”
― Hunter S. Thompson

Top
#257525 - 02/18/12 10:05 PM Re: tiny stout yeast trial [Re: gobucks747]
gobucks747 Offline
“Good people drink good beer.” HST
Jr. Mr Beer Fan
*

Registered: 10/14/11
Posts: 113
Loc: Haverhill, MA
results time!

So after failing to prime the english yeast, a week at 70 degrees and they primed fine. a few more weeks in the fridge I am ready for results.

American yeast: This was clearer, more carbonated, and less "stout" tasting.

English: After having to up the temp to get it to bottle prime, I will never use an American yeast again for stout. This was wonderful The carbonation held a great head, and it had a cloudier look. The taste was more of a mouthful and mildly bitter. After about 7-8 stout trials with various ingredients, I think I have found a new favorite. This makes me curious what some of the old recipes would have tasted like with an english yeast. Safale s-04, you are my new best friend....us-05, I will see you when the weather gets warm and the light brews are back in rotation
_________________________
Fermenting: empty
Fermenting: empty
Fermenting: empty
Conditioning: motts hard cider
Conditioning: Double Wheres the honey stout
Conditioning: Yeast trial stouts
drinking: Muntons Mexican
drinking: Oatmeal red v2.0



Drinking: Double Straw(cherry) ale

“Good people drink good beer.”
― Hunter S. Thompson

Top


Shout Box

Mr.Beer How-To Videos

New to brewing? The following videos will help you make sense of your new hobby. The videos will walk you through every step of the process—from sanitizing to bottling and everything in between.
Recent Pictures
Bewenched Red Ale Label
Fourplay Mead Label
Threesome Hefeweizen Label
Sloppy Seconds Dirty Blonde Ale Label
Maiden Pale Ale Label
New Topics
Bewenched Red Ale
by Jacylrin
05/18/12 02:06 PM
Cellaring Beers
by jwupun
05/18/12 09:04 AM
Happy Birthday Frosty!
by BEERKEEPER
05/17/12 11:34 PM
Seems to be my lucky night.
by SaltyBacon
05/17/12 11:07 PM
Road Runner IPA
by Dan_Hills
05/17/12 10:25 PM

MR.BEER® is a registered trademark of Catalina Products LLC DBA www.mrbeer.com. Used by permission.